Matthew Schaefer Props
Upcoming Events
Matthew Schaefer's event has concluded. Their next event is Islanders New York NYI @ Wild Minnesota MIN on January 11, 2026 1:00 AM. View the betting markets below to get an idea of what may be available for upcoming events.
Previous Event
Matthew Schaefer (D) of the New York Islanders is going up against The Nashville Predators on January 08, 2026 at 8:00 PM ET. They have 115 bets across 14 sportsbooks. Check out the odds below, or view them directly in Gambly chat for the most up-to-date odds.
Opening Lines
Bet All
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+125
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Anytime Goalscorer
+350
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 1.5
Goals Scored
1.5
+2500
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Shots on Goal
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Assists
-10000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Goals Scored
-10000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Power Play Points
-10000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-115
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-142
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+100
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-112
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Shots on Goal Game Leader
+650
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Anytime Goalscorer
+380
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Last Goalscorer
+2000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Third Period Anytime Goalscorer
+1200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+120
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+135
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-500
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+110
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-125
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Third Period First Goalscorer
+2500
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-510
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Second Period Points
0.5
+300
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+102
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-208
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-164
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-122
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+134
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+110
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
First Period Shots on Goal
0.5
-136
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-120
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
First Period Points
0.5
+330
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+330
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Anytime Goalscorer
+0.5
+370
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-114
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-159
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-125
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-112
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-112
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-140
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-155
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Points
-10000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+333
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 1.5
Goals Scored
1.5
+4000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-667
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+253
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Goals Scored
0.5
+512
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+332
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+115
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 24.25
Player Time on Ice
24.25
-118
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-105
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+320
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-130
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Second Period Last Goalscorer
+2200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+102
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+105
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-118
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-132
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+138
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Last Goalscorer
+0.5
+2435
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
First Goalscorer
+0.5
+2435
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+114
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Second Period Anytime Goalscorer
+1000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-121
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
First Period Anytime Goalscorer
+1300
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-135
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-115
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Second Period Shots on Goal
0.5
-148
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Third Period Shots on Goal
0.5
-144
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-190
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+130
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-510
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+305
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-105
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Second Goalscorer
+2200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Score 3 or More Goals
+20000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 24.25
Player Time on Ice
24.25
-118
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-102
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 1.5
Shots on Goal
1.5
-240
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Second Period First Goalscorer
+2200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-120
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-455
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-110
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
First Period Shots on Goal
0.5
-144
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-179
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+310
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+135
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-105
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
+325
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-104
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+133
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Score 2 or More Goals
+3500
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Power Play Points
0.5
-445
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+135
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-120
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
First Goalscorer
+2200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Anytime Goalscorer
+400
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Last Goalscorer
+2200
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-175
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-175
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
-180
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-130
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Assists
0.5
+120
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-118
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-137
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Goals Scored
0.5
-1000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Goals Scored
0.5
+500
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-160
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+130
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
-130
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 0.5
Points
0.5
+100
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
+110
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
Anytime Goalscorer
+380
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer
First Goalscorer
+2000
NSH @ NYI
Today at 1:00 AM
Matthew Schaefer Under 2.5
Shots on Goal
2.5
-150
The Best Books To Bet Matthew Schaefer Props
- Assists: The best book to bet Assists is Novig, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 0.5) at +138.
- Anytime Goalscorer: The best book to bet Anytime Goalscorer is FanDuel, which offers Matthew Schaefer +1300.
- Goals Scored: The best book to bet Goals Scored is DraftKings, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 1.5) at +4000.
- Shots on Goal: The best book to bet Shots on Goal is Underdog, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 2.5) at +133.
- Power Play Points: The best book to bet Power Play Points is Novig, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 0.5) at +333.
- Points: The best book to bet Points is DraftKings, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 0.5) at +330.
- Shots on Goal Game Leader: The best book to bet Shots on Goal Game Leader is DraftKings, which offers Matthew Schaefer +650.
- Last Goalscorer: The best book to bet Last Goalscorer is Fliff, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 0.5) at +2435.
- First Goalscorer: The best book to bet First Goalscorer is FanDuel, which offers Matthew Schaefer +2500.
- Player Time on Ice: The best book to bet Player Time on Ice is PrizePicks, which offers Matthew Schaefer (O 24.3) at -118.
- Second Goalscorer: The best book to bet Second Goalscorer is FanDuel, which offers Matthew Schaefer +2200.
- Score 3 or More Goals: The best book to bet Score 3 or More Goals is FanDuel, which offers Matthew Schaefer +20000.
- Score 2 or More Goals: The best book to bet Score 2 or More Goals is FanDuel, which offers Matthew Schaefer +3500.
Line Shopping & Betting Tips
Maximizing your potential returns starts with finding the best lines across multiple sportsbooks. Even a small shift in odds can lead to better payouts, so it pays to compare. Always keep an eye on Murray's listed props - you never know when a book might offer more favorable odds.